Archive for the ‘Ranting’ Category

Why are we still using Alexa Rankings?

Wednesday, July 18th, 2007

I went to text-link-ads.com to add Hide This Thing to my available inventory of site space, and it would not accept the site because its Alexa Ranking was not high enough. This got me to thinking “why is anyone still using Alexa Ranking as a proper metric for anything?”

I did a little research on why this ranking is relevant, and confirmed my suspicions that this is a very unrepresentative way to measure traffic. The main reason is because Alexa Rankings gather data from browsers that have the Alexa Toolbar for Internet Explorer or Sparky for Firefox installed. The vast majority of everyday traffic will not have this installed. The most likely visitors to your site that will have these toolbars installed will be webmasters and savvy users who care about search engine optimization. If you’re running a site that has content that is primarily webmaster/tech related, then you’re probably all set, but that’s a pretty narrow slice of the web. The rest of the sites out there end up getting a potentially inaccurate snapshot of their user base on Alexa.

During my research I found a few SEO blogs that gave tips on how to increase a site’s Alexa Ranking. Most of them seem pretty hoky… at least for a measurement system that has as much power as it apparently does.

Here are a few items that I found on SEO Book regarding the subject that I thought I’d share:

  • Download the Alexa Toolbar and surf your own site.
  • Have a few friends download the Alexa Toolbar and surf your site.
  • Shift the focus of your site toward a more webmaster like theme.
  • Participate in many webmaster forums which allow you to place your site in your signature.
  • Write articles about webmaster topics and distribute them around the web.
  • Write an article with tips on how to increase your Alexa rankings.

What everyday site owner is going to do any of that? The web, especially the blog world, is not always maintained by server savvy folk such as myself (and probably you, my dear handsome reader).

I’m not going to suddenly change the focus of my site to webmaster themes just because that will attract the people that most likely have the toolbar installed! However, apparently I will write an article about Alexa Rankings. ;)

Would I love all my visitors to install the Alexa Toolbar and visit all the sites I’ve created? Sure, but even I’m not that big of a beggar.

[tags]alexa, seo, search engine optimization, alexa ranking[/tags]

Mac vs. PC… Good question? Not really.

Monday, May 14th, 2007

It’s not often that I write letters to officials, news stations, or any of those things, but tonight was my one for the year (or so). Our local NBC station has a segment called Good Question on the 10:00 news, and tonight’s segment that attempted to solve the Mac vs. PC debate was just shoddy, lazy, reporting. Here was my e-mail to the station:

I was rather disappointed to watch your recent segment on the Mac vs. PC debate. Although all points were valid, I felt that they were presented in a way that was slightly misleading.

Point 1: Yes, there are Macs that cost upwards of $3000 or more. However, the Mac Pro is a very high powered machine that is built with video and audio editors in mind. The average viewer of your segment would mostly be using their computer for e-mail and Internet surfing, which the $499 mac mini is more than suitable (and within the price range of a comparable PC). Even if they went for an iMac, the most they’d pay is $1800.

Point 2: Graphic Design? I’m a designer at one of the top advertising agencies in town, and even though I am a Mac user (I switched from PC in Fall 2005), the PC versions of all the design programs I use are exactly the same. This is kind of a cop out.

Point 3: This is really the only point in the entire battle that has no real counterpoint. You can’t argue numbers like that.

Point 4:
Downtime? I personally have only had any Mac freeze up a handful of times, but it should be pointed out that ALL computers crash, no matter the operating system. That’s just a fact of life. I could argue however that a PC freezes far more often than Mac… the main reason I switched platforms.

Finally, I bring up the point that was unfortunately missed in your report. I am writing this email from a Macbook laptop, which is capable of running Mac OS X and Windows XP… a feat that no PC on the market can do without illegal software hacking.

The fact of the matter is that it’s not a draw, but there’s no clear winner either… only because each computer platform serves people in different ways, and that’s just how it should be. A Mac is not for everyone just as a PC is the same. I’d love for everyone to use Macs, but for some people cost or perceived lack of software is a deal breaker.

I should also point out that I’m not trying to start a platform war here… Those are more lame and awful than the segment itself. I’m just pointing out that their research and delivery of the information was lackluster on both sides of the issue.

“Camping out” for a Wii in May

Monday, May 7th, 2007

My brother-in-law and I went and waited in line for a Wii this past Saturday. Well, I say waited in line, but it really wasn’t like that.

wii_crotch.jpgPete’s been looking for a Wii for a couple of months… basically 20 minutes after he started playing mine. We found out that Wal-Mart was going to have an undetermined stock at stores in the Kansas City area at 12:01 this past Sunday. The Wal-Mart by his house had a sign up in the game section announcing their availability, so we anticipated the possibility of long lines of people who have been searching for months as well. Around 10:30 on Saturday night we gave up our turns at Wii Bowling at my place and headed over to the nearest Wal-Mart. Luckily, there was no sign at this location, which meant we were the first to arrive. We felt a little silly being the only ones in our little waiting line, but we knew if we were to leave and come back even 15 minutes later we’d probably lose our place. We stayed.

We waited around for about 45 minutes before someone asked if they could help us, and once she learned we were waiting for a Wii, she gave Pete a slip of paper that reserved one of the units for him. After that, we went to a bar across the street for a few beers before heading back around 12:10 to pick up one of the four units they received. The search had ended, and now I wouldn’t have to pack up my Wii and all its accessories any time we wanted to go over to Pete’s house on a Saturday night. Plus, he bought Trauma Center: Second Opinion, which I’ve been wanting to try. Bonus.

Does anyone else find it slightly odd that it’s a little over 7 months since the release of the Nintendo Wii, yet they’re still nearly impossible to find?

eb_dork.jpgA month or so ago I was trying to make small talk with an EB Games employee when I went in to ask if they had any Wiis available, and I suggested that perhaps Nintendo was sitting on a large portion of their stock just to reinforce how popular this console has been compared to the Playstation 3 and Xbox 360. I expected a polite yet awkward dialogue about the subject, but this guy acted like I had made out with his mom right in front of him. I finally had all of his bitching and fanboy posturing that I could stand and left the store mid-conversation.

What do you think? Other popular gaming consoles have overcome their stock shortages in less time than this. Especially with the Wii being made of more commonplace components, what could be causing this shortage, if indeed there really is one?

Incidentally, I’ve stopped going to that EB Games location. Big tip… don’t treat your customers like schmucks. Being socially inept doesn’t excuse poor customer service.

// RELATED UPDATE: Ad Age published an interesting article about the wait for Wiis and when that might end.